by Catherine Giordano
HBO’s
Real Time with Bill Maher, episode
277, airing on April 5, 2013, could have been a great show. Bernie
Sanders, a self-avowed socialist senator from Vermont (who is an
Independent, but caucuses with the Democrats) was on the panel. I think he is
the smartest person in the room, no matter what room he is in. Unfortunately,
the discussion was brought down to a third-grade level by Big Foot (Steve Moore, conservative author and
total moron) and The Mouth (Abby
Huntsman, daughter of former Republican presidential candidate, Jon Huntsman, who currently
writes for the Huffington Post).
During
the show, Bill mentioned the Public Policy Poll, which discovered that
Americans have some really stupid beliefs, especially Republican-Americans. He
mentioned that 14% believe that “Big Foot” is real. If Big Foot is real, his
name is Steve Moore. He sat on the panel and stomped on every intelligent thing
anyone else said. There is something wrong with that man. During the first few minutes he started shouted
and flailing his arms around, practically falling off his chair. He acts and
talks like a lunatic, and when he is called out for his fantastically wrong
assertions, all he can do is grin goofily and launch himself into a new attack.
I
nicknamed Abby Huntsman “The Mouth” because she interrupted the other
panelists constantly and never had anything worthwhile to say. For instance, during
a discussion of gay marriage, even though she said she favors it, she had to
bring up bestiality and polygamy, just as all the right-wing nuts who oppose it
do. She struck me as “daddy’s darling” who has a much-too-high opinion of
herself. Her father is very good looking and she inherited his good looks--she’s
a beautiful young woman. Too bad she didn’t inherit his brains—Jon Huntsman
was the only intelligent person on the stage during the Republican debates. Instead
of adopting the demeanor of her father--calm, rational, well-informed--she
choose to be a bombastic fool. And Abby,
if you want to be taken seriously, tone down the makeup—you looked like you
were auditioning for the Elizabeth Taylor role in “Cleopatra.”
Poor
Bernie, he had to have the patience of a saint dealing with these two. Bernie
would try to explain something, one or both would interrupt him and go off on a
rant, but Bernie would not be deterred. As soon as he could get a word in
edgewise is get back to making his point, using facts not opinions. I really admired him for that.
Later,
the special guest was Zach Koppin,
a 19-year old young man who is making a name for himself challenging the
Louisiana Science Education Act” will allow teachers to bring unauthorized materials
into the classroom in order to teach creationism and argue against climate
science. Zach and Abby are both young,
and that is about all they have in common. Zach spoke calmly without raising
his voice, smiled affably, and supported his well-reasoned conclusions and opinions
with facts. (Abby ranted and preened and
spouted “talking points.”)
Zach
told us the Bobby Jindal, governor of Luoisiana, signed this law. Bill scoffed referring to Jindal’s recent statement
about Republicans being the stupid party. (If he doesn’t want Republicans to be
the stupid party, he needs to repeal this law.)
According
to the Public Policy Poll, 46% of Americans believe in creationism, 37% believe
global warming is a hoax, 22% believe Obama is the Anti-Christ, and 14% believe
Big Foot exists. (P.S. Belief in crazy stuff is higher among Republicans.)
I
think these erroneous beliefs are all related, and religion is the root cause. Religion
teaches people to believe something without evidence as well as to believe something
is true just because you want it to be true. Consequently, it becomes easy for people
seeped in religion to believe all kinds of crazy things. Also, it is exciting to believe in crazy
things. Most of us lead boring lives—how
interesting to think there are all manner of conspiracies swirling around us
and mythical creatures like Big Foot exist.
Here
are the facts about climate change. Given the position of the Earth relative to
the Sun, we should be in a mini ice-age right now. However, the higher concentration of carbon
in the atmosphere, due to civilization, has prevented this ice age; Not only
have global temperatures not fallen, they have increased. The Earth will
survive this. Civilization may not—sea levels will rise inundating coastal
areas and low lying islands, storms will become more frequent and more
destructive, farming will be disrupted, and on and on. It may already be too
late to reverse this, but perhaps we can keep things from getting a lot worse.
Zach
talked about the importance of science and the dangers of cutting funding for
science as the Sequester is doing. The Human Genome project had a return on investment
of $140 to $1. This is Steve’s cue to
bring up a study about the mating habits of snails. (How predictable!) Bernie chastised
him saying that the four largest corporations in America are paying zero income
taxes, but you want to blame all our economic problems on the relatively tiny
spending on a science project. (I remember learning about pure research and
applied research in school. The findings of pure research may someday be
applied to produce astounding benefits.)
The
interview was with Sebastian Junger,
a journalist and documentarian who has an HBO special airing soon, titled “Which
Way is the Front Line From Here. “ He spoke about the psychology of warriors--the
“band-of-brothers” emotional ties and the “adrenaline high” soldiers get from
combat. I learned that 978 journalists have been killed in war zones in the
last twenty year. Sebastian said that “Democracy is not possible without the
press.” These men and women risk their lives to give us the truth—the least we
can do is listen.
In
New Rules, Bill tried to address the flak he gets about libertarianism. It was the “I-didn’t-leave-them,-they–left–me”
moment of the week. Bill poked fun the
juvenile thinking of present-day followers of Ayn Rand.
Bill
compared the Ayn Rand libertarians to people who see a stop light and don’t
think about traffic safety—they think “how dare the government tell me I can’t
go.” Their take on seat belts is “It is
my right to soar free as an eagle—right through the windshield.” And as for meat inspections:Let people sniff
their own meat and if a few people die word will get out not to eat the T-Bone
at the Ponderosa and the Ponderosa will go out of business—the free market in
action.”
Bill
once described himself as a libertarian because he didn’t want government making
laws about sex or drugs and other personal issues, but the current libertarians—like
Paul Ryan and Rand Paul—have defined him out of the group. They don’t think
that government should regulate banks, guns, schools, civil rights, or even
provide help after a disaster. They hate environmental regulations, Social Security,
and Medicare. Bill says, “It beats stepping over lepers and watching human
skeletons sh*t in the river. I’m just
selfish that way.”
There
were some good guests this week, especially Bernie, but they had to fight to be
heard over Big Foot and The Mouth. I can only hope that Bill is not so
desperate for panel members that he will invite these two back. (Especially not
Steve Moore. Please please, please, no
more Steve Moore.)
A picture of Big Foot. |
Bernie Sanders and Steve Moore were way out of line with their hand gestures in front of Abby Huntman...
ReplyDeleteI didn't notice any hand gestures except for Steve Moore flailing has hands around. Bernie Sanders is the epitome of a gentleman--I can't imagine him making any inappropriate hand gestures.
DeleteIt looked like the were just ignoring her because clearly she is an idiot and was far too interested in hair and makeup rather than having anything substantial to say. She should have sat at the kids table.
ReplyDeleteThe kid's table--I like that image. And Steve Moore should have been made to sit in the corner as punishment for telling lies.
DeleteI watch every episode of Realtime, this was one the better ones. Bernie Sanders made Moore and Huntman look like the fools they are. I thought Abby Huntman was annoying and had no business on the show. Her comments were off the wall nuts.I can not believe she works for Huffington post. Steve Moore's views on the economy, were insane. They need dump the opening interviews(boring) and extend the panel time. The mid show guest are becoming lame and should change that up.
ReplyDeleteYou are exactly right about Abby Huntsman having no business on the show. She was there because of who her father is; not for anything she has done. The interviews and the mid-show guests are only as interesting as the person appearing in that slot. Sometimes I like those segments and sometimes I don't.
ReplyDelete